Somebody posted this on Twitter (X, yes I know, but…) yesterday, and I responded to it, saying it felt like victim blaming to me. They got a bit narky about it, and said it was really important to them, so I dropped it. Whatever gets you through the night, I guess. I don’t want to tear down something that helps somebody. But I can’t stop thinking about it, and this is my space – and I’m assuming that if you’re reading this, you’re interested in those thoughts. So here goes. Hopefully this will get it out of my system, and I’ll sleep a bit better tonight.
First of all, I think I hit the descriptor for being in radical remission. I’m certainly a super survivor. When I was first diagnosed, it was unlikely that I’d see my kids through primary school. My daughter is now doing a Master’s degree and my son’s in his second year at uni, so I have definitely beaten the odds. I didn’t do any of those things.
The poster didn’t give any citation, so I haven’t read the original paper, so I’m not critiquing that, I’m just making points and asking questions.
My first point is: here I am. Interview me about what I’ve been doing to live so long with such a poor prognosis. I’ll tell you whatever you want to know. Since I was diagnosed, in my close friendship group there have been 3 more people diagnosed with poor prognosis cancers. They were all beautiful, talented vibrant people. They all had children who loved and needed them. They all loved and were loved. They had amazing lives. You can’t interview them. They’re all dead. They might have done all of these things, but they died anyway. How would you know?
Secondly, it’s notoriously hard to pinpoint what makes people live longer. The Mediterranean diet works brilliantly round the Med. It doesn’t seem to work so well in Birmingham. If you look at the interviews with 100 year olds, they are always asked what the secret is. They all have different answers – oh, I never married – oh, I have a glass of wine and a cigarette every evening – oh, I eat porridge every day. We are creatures who crave narrative – cause and effect, and who crave agency. We desperately want to be captains of our souls.
This post ignores luck. The Romans worshipped the goddess Fortuna, and she has many aspects. When I say worship, I suspect it was more about propriation, about nudging. She’s a much more powerful goddess than we like to admit.
Look at me. I was lucky to be born into a nice, middle class family who had the emotional and financial resources to support me. I was lucky to meet my husband, who has been an amazing partner and support and rock and source of joy for over 30 years. I was lucky to have 2 wanted, beautiful, healthy children. I didn’t depend on luck. I worked hard in my career, I work hard to be the best parent I can, I try to be as good a partner as I can. Machiavelli reckoned it was 50:50, luck and work. I intuitively feel that’s about right. And with this cancer thing, I honestly, truly believe that I have been lucky. I was unlucky to get it – no family history, healthy lifestyle – and I’ve been lucky to live this long with it. And my beautiful, talented, lost friends? They were unlucky.
I think it’s the last point on that list that really gets to me. “Having strong reasons for living”. As if really wanting to live is going to change things. It feeds into the battle language that I find so hard to stomach. I’m not stronger, I’m not braver, I’m not hungrier for life. I’m just lucky. Saying otherwise feels like an insult to those beautiful people who didn’t survive this long, and I won’t accept that. They deserve better. That’s the one thing in this I’m prepared to fight for.